Hayle Station Crossing to be Closed?

There is widespread disquiet in Hayle following Network Rail's proposal for the closure of the Hayle pedestrian crossing at Hayle Railway station which as received he backing of Andrew George MP.

Currently access to/from the Truro bound line from the station car park is by walking over the tracks at the light controlled pedestrian crossing.  It was reported in the local press a few weeks ago that a tragic incident was only just avoided when a number of passengers ignored the warning lights, crossed the tracks and were only moments away from being struck by a high-speed train..
 

Hayle Railway Crossing
Local MP Mr George has called for the crossing to be closed and either the old footbridge  to be reinstated or an alternative route under the nearby road bridge be provided. However this has not met with universal approval.

People have been quick to point out that the current crossing, if used properly is not only safe but provides convenient level access for the elderly, disabled and those with pushchairs, heavy luggage or cycles and that a footbridge would be a retrograde step. It could also be incompatible with current disability legislation.

Hayle Level Crossing Sign

An alternative route to the platform under the nearby road bridge is also thought by many to be too inconvenient as it would involve a substantial walk down a quite steep hill, under the bridge and then a climb again at the other side along narrow roads with no footpath.

Perhaps a better idea would be to make the pedestrian signals more prominent with 'WALK' and DON'T WALK signs so there can be no confusion as to whether the signals are supposes to apply to trains or pedestrians and/or perhaps an automatic pedestrian barrier could be used.

What do you think? - have your say in our discussion forum